Skip to content
Service in English, Punjabi and Hindi Serving all of BC (604) 773-4392
Shergill Law Corporation

Mediation

Couples Mediation or Two Lawyers? How to Choose for Your Separation in Surrey

Mandy Shergill3 November 20267 min read

Most separating couples assume they each need a lawyer. Many do not, at least not for the whole process. Here is how to tell which route fits your situation.

A separating couple at a signpost choosing between couples mediation and two lawyers

The short answer

Choose couples mediation if you can still talk, both of you will share your finances honestly, and you want to make the decisions yourselves. Choose two lawyers if there has been family violence or intimidation, one of you is hiding money, or you need a court order quickly.

Most separating couples in BC fall somewhere in between, and a common route is a blend: mediate the decisions together, then each take the draft agreement to your own lawyer before signing. One lawyer cannot act for both of you, so even in mediation, each person ends up with separate advice.

How each route works

In couples mediation you negotiate directly with each other, with a neutral mediator running the room. With two lawyers, each of you instructs an advocate, and the negotiation happens between them through letters, calls and meetings.

Couples mediation Two lawyers
Who negotiates The two of you, face to face Your lawyers, on your instructions
Who is on your side Nobody in the room; the mediator is neutral Your own lawyer, at every step
Legal advice Before and after, from your own lawyer Throughout
Pace Set by you; often weeks Set by two lawyers' calendars; often months
Tone Built for cooperation Can become positional
Typical result A separation agreement A separation agreement, or a court order if talks fail
Confidentiality Mediation discussions are generally private and without prejudice Settlement talks are private; a court file is public

Both routes usually end the same way, with a signed separation agreement. The difference is how you get there, and how much it costs along the way.

What each route costs

Couples mediation usually costs less because you share one professional's time instead of paying two for every exchange. The gap widens with every round of letters a two-lawyer negotiation needs.

Couples mediation Two lawyers
Main fee One mediator at $250 to $500 an hour, split between you Each lawyer at their own hourly rate, $225 to $500 on average in BC
Typical total for the main work About $1,500 to $7,500 for the mediator, shared $4,000 to $19,000 for a separation agreement involving children; $2,000 to $5,000 without children
Extra costs Each person's independent legal advice before signing Valuations, and court fees if talks break down

The lawyer figures are averages published by Crease Harman LLP, a BC law firm, in their guide to divorce costs in BC. For a full breakdown of mediation fees, see how much a family mediator costs in BC.

Cost is not a reason to pick mediation when it is unsafe or one-sided. A cheap agreement signed under pressure, or without full disclosure, can be set aside later and cost far more to fix.

When couples mediation is the better choice

Couples mediation works best when both of you can say yes to most of these statements:

  • We can sit in the same room and discuss money and the children without one of us shutting down or being afraid.
  • We will both share full financial information: income, accounts, pensions, debts and anything held overseas.
  • Neither of us needs an urgent court order to protect a child, a home or a bank account.
  • We broadly agree on the big picture, such as who stays in the home, and need help with the details.
  • We want to keep co-parenting, family relationships or a shared community intact.
  • We would rather decide the outcome ourselves than have a judge decide it.

If most of these are true, couples mediation in Surrey will usually be faster and cheaper, and the agreement tends to hold because you both built it.

When each of you should hire a lawyer instead

Two lawyers, negotiating on your behalf, are the safer route in any of these situations:

  • Family violence, threats or coercive control. Every BC family mediator must screen for family violence under section 8 of the Family Law Act, and joint mediation may be declined or restructured when it is present. If you are not safe, see protection orders and safety planning in BC.
  • Hidden or moving money. If one person is refusing disclosure, transferring assets or draining accounts, a lawyer can seek court orders that a mediator cannot.
  • An urgent problem. A parent threatening to leave BC with the children, or a home about to be sold, needs a court application now, not a mediation date.
  • A large imbalance in knowledge or confidence. If one person has always handled the finances or the paperwork, the other may struggle to negotiate as an equal without an advocate.
  • One person will not engage. Mediation is voluntary. If your former partner will not take part, or keeps cancelling, a lawyer can move the matter forward.

Choosing lawyers does not mean going to court. Most files negotiated through lawyers still settle with a signed agreement.

The middle path: mediation with lawyers advising

You do not have to choose one route completely. Many couples mediate the decisions together and use lawyers only at the points where advice matters most, which keeps most of the savings while protecting both people.

  1. Advice before you start. Each person has a short consultation with their own lawyer to learn their rights and likely range.
  2. Mediation together. You work through parenting, support and property with the mediator, exchanging disclosure as you go.
  3. Advice between sessions, if needed. A quick call with your lawyer before agreeing to anything you are unsure about.
  4. Independent legal advice before signing. Each lawyer reviews the draft agreement with their own client.
  5. Sign. The agreement is signed and witnessed, and can be filed with the court so the parenting and support terms are enforceable.

Where the issues are complex, lawyers can also attend the mediation with their clients, or the two lawyers and both of you can meet together in a four-way settlement meeting.

How to decide, and where to start in Surrey

Start by asking the screening questions honestly, ideally each on your own: can you both speak freely, will you both disclose everything, and is anything urgent? If the answers are yes, yes and no, try couples mediation first. You can always switch to lawyers if it stalls, and anything already agreed stays agreed.

At Shergill Law, both routes are available from our office on Croydon Drive in South Surrey:

  • Couples mediation with Mandy Shergill, a family lawyer called to the BC Bar in 2014 and an accredited family mediator with Mediate BC, in English, Punjabi or Hindi. Because Mandy is neutral as your mediator, each of you takes the draft agreement to a lawyer at a different firm for independent legal advice.
  • One person's own lawyer. If you would rather have an advocate, Mandy, Ramneet Sidhu or Gurpreet Seera can act for you, negotiate with your former partner's lawyer, and draft or review your separation agreement.

Mandy's mediation rates are affordable and are explained at a consultation. Call (604) 773-4392 or request a consultation to talk through which route fits your situation.

Frequently asked questions

Is couples mediation better than hiring lawyers?

It is usually cheaper and faster when both people can negotiate safely and disclose honestly. Lawyers are the better choice where there is family violence, hidden assets, an urgent issue or a large imbalance between the two of you.

Can one lawyer represent both of us in a separation?

No. A lawyer cannot act for both spouses in a separation because your interests conflict. A mediator can work with both of you, but stays neutral and advises neither.

Do we each still need a lawyer if we use a mediator?

Yes, for independent legal advice before you sign. It is a short step compared with full representation, and it is one of the main reasons an agreement holds up if it is challenged later.

Can we start with mediation and switch to lawyers later?

Yes. Mediation is voluntary and either person can end it. Anything you have already agreed in writing can be kept, and lawyers pick up the remaining issues.

Is a mediated separation agreement legally binding in BC?

Once it is written up, signed by both of you and witnessed, it is binding. It can be filed with the court so the parenting and support terms are enforceable like a court order.

What if my spouse refuses couples mediation?

Mediation is voluntary, so you cannot make your spouse take part in couples mediation. In a BC Supreme Court family case, either person can serve a Notice to Mediate, which requires attendance at a mediation session unless an exemption, such as family violence, applies.

Can we do couples mediation in Punjabi or Hindi in Surrey?

Yes. Mandy Shergill mediates in English, Punjabi and Hindi at our South Surrey office.

Share this article

LinkedIn Facebook Email

This article is general information about family law in British Columbia. It is not legal advice for your situation. Speak with a lawyer about the facts of your own matter.

Related reading

All insights

Where we practise

Surrey Delta Langley White Rock Richmond Burnaby Abbotsford Vancouver

Service across the Lower Mainland from our Surrey office, in English, Punjabi and Hindi. We also act for clients living outside Canada with a family law matter in British Columbia.

Next step

Talk to someone who does this every day.

Serving Surrey, Delta, Langley, White Rock, Richmond, Burnaby, Abbotsford and Vancouver, in English, Punjabi and Hindi.

Call now Request consultation